Why did i get a positive and negative pregnancy test

Why could the first pregnancy test be positive and the second test not be positive?

If you’re trying to get pregnant time can stand still when you’re taking a pregnancy test. You know you are only waiting a couple of minutes, but it seems like the clock stopped ticking and the world is in a frozen state where the test will simply not turn one way or the other. When the test reads positive, you jump for joy and immediately run out to get another one to “make sure” the positive test was truly positive. What happens if the second test is not positive? Does it mean that you’re not pregnant?

How does a pregnancy test work?

Home pregnancy tests work by testing for the presence of HCG the human chorionic gonadotropin in your urine. You want to follow the instructions exactly as they are written so you wait for the first morning urine and you use that to test. hCG levels are higher in the morning than any other time of day, so if you are JUST pregnant enough to test positive, the pregnancy test will turn and you’ll be thrilled. And you need to read the results exactly at the right time. Reading it too early or later will potentially give you an incorrect result.

Then, you jump up and run out for the second test. This time you wait until you have to go to the bathroom and you take the second test. Your urine is now potentially diluted the second time around and the test suddenly reads negative. The reason for getting a negative test with more diluted urine is that the concentration, the amount of HCG per urine volme is less. The negative test causes you to be extremely sad you start your search for information about why the first pregnancy test is positive and the second negative – that’s how you arrived at this specific article.

What should you do?

Wait until the following morning to test again with the first morning urine. If the test is still negative – keep the positive test and the second negative morning test or take a picture of both side by side. Make an appointment with your Ob-Gyn to have a blood pregnancy test if available. Or, you can choose to wait another week and test again. Between the 3rd and 5th week of gestation hCG levels rise dramatically and the test will be positive no matter what time of day you test.

Read More:
What Causes a Negative Test?
Online Pregnancy Test
Pregnancy Week-by-Week

Maybe you can’t wait to have a baby. Or maybe that’s the last thing you’re hoping for.

Cleveland Clinic is a non-profit academic medical center. Advertising on our site helps support our mission. We do not endorse non-Cleveland Clinic products or services. Policy

Either way, if you think you might be pregnant, you need to know for sure. But what are the odds a positive pregnancy test might be wrong?

“Home urine pregnancy tests are pretty reliable,” says Ob/Gyn Jonathan Emery, MD. “But there are some reasons you might get a false-positive result.”

Dr. Emery explains when and why a pregnancy test might give a false positive — and what you can do to make sure the stick doesn’t lie.

How do pregnancy tests work?

When you get pregnant, your body produces a hormone called human chorionic gonadotropin, or hCG. Home pregnancy tests look for that hormone in your urine. If hCG is present, you should get a positive test result when you pee on a stick.

But hCG levels start out very low and increase over time. If you take the test too soon after conceiving, it might say you’re not pregnant when you really are.

In other words, timing can lead to a false negative. But what about a false positive?

False positives aren’t super common, Dr. Emery says. But they’re not impossible. Some potential causes include:

Early miscarriage or chemical pregnancy

You took a pregnancy test and got two lines. (Positive!) But a few days later, your period arrived in force. What gives? The most common reason this happens is an early pregnancy loss, also known as a chemical pregnancy. In this case, the test was accurate — there was a pregnancy, but it wasn’t a viable one, Dr. Emery explains.

“It’s not technically false since a very early pregnancy did occur,” he says. “But this is the most common reason that a pregnancy test might appear to have been false.”    

Fertility medications

“A lot of fertility treatments involve taking hCG injections,” Dr. Emery says. If you’ve been taking fertility medications, that hCG might still be floating around your system.

That could trigger a positive pregnancy test, even if you’re not pregnant. To avoid that mix-up, wait at least two weeks after your last hCG injection to take a home pregnancy test, he says.

Recent pregnancy

If you were recently pregnant, you might still have leftover hCG in your system. After childbirth, miscarriage or treatment for ectopic pregnancy, the hormone can remain in your body for up to four to six weeks, Dr. Emery says. “That could lead to a positive pregnancy test when your body just hasn’t cleared the hCG yet.”

User error

Home pregnancy tests aren’t especially hard to use. But you still have to pay attention since a mistake can lead to incorrect results.

If you wait too long to read the results, for example, or use more drops of urine than the test calls for? You might want to take the answer with a grain of salt. “If you don’t follow all the instructions, any results — positive or negative — could be false,” Dr. Emery says.

Pregnancy test accuracy: How to get results you can trust

Luckily, false positives are rare. And there are steps you can take to make sure your home pregnancy test gives you results you can trust.

• Time it right. Don’t take a test too early. It’s more likely that you’ll get a false negative — or that the test will detect a chemical pregnancy that isn’t able to progress. Dr. Emery recommends waiting until the day of your missed period, or a few days later, to take the test. “Timing is important. The test is most accurate if you wait at least until the day of your expected period,” he says.
• Follow the directions. Make sure your test isn’t expired. Read the directions before you start. And follow the steps exactly to avoid a stressful false result.
• Repeat it. If you got a positive home pregnancy test, you might be eager to get a blood test to confirm the result. Blood tests are more accurate, so that’s certainly an option. But it isn’t always necessary, Dr. Emery says. “If you get a positive result from a urine test, then repeat the test in three to five days. If it’s still positive, you can trust the result,” he says.

Home pregnancy tests are inexpensive, private and quite reliable, Dr. Emery adds. “People often don’t believe what they’re seeing. But if you’ve used the test correctly and done it at the right time, it’s probably true.”