Is a washer with an agitator better

When your washer flatlines, quickly scoring a new machine can give your laundry room a new lease on life—before the clothes start piling up. But should you choose a modern front-loader, a water-saving high-efficiency model, or a traditional top-load agitator like mom and dad used to have?

If it’s the latter, you’re not alone. Top-load agitator washing machines aren’t the most technologically innovative, but they continue to outsell front-loaders and even HE top-loaders, the kind without a center-post agitator. According to the Association of Home Appliance Manufacturers, 44 percent of all washer shipments in 2020 were top-load agitators. Updated stats for 2021 were unavailable, but judging by the continued popularity of top-loaders, an increase was expected.

One reason is cost. “They’re often your least expensive type of washer, typically about $550 and up,” says Mark Allwood, a senior market analyst at CR. Almost half the agitator top-loaders in our washing machine ratings sell for $700 or less.

And there are plenty of selling points. Mold doesn’t seem to be a problem (unlike with some front-loaders), according to our survey of 106,633 CR members who purchased a new machine between 2011 and 2021. They clean clothes faster, too. Most agitator washer cycles clock in between 35 and 70 minutes in our tests. HE top-loaders usually take between 60 and 80 minutes, and front-loaders take 75 to 120 minutes. (We use the normal-wash/heavy-soil setting in our tests; a normal-soil setting takes less time.)

But HE top-loaders and front-loaders shorten dryer time because they use less water than most agitator washers and extract more of it during the spin cycle.

Think a new top-load agitator might be right for you? Below are five key considerations to keep in mind. CR members can read on for ratings and reviews of four high-scoring agitator washers from our tests. Not sure which type of washer to choose? Consult our washing machine buying guide as you shop. The check our washing machine ratings for details on more than 100 agitator top-loaders, HE top-loaders, and front-loaders.

Only 10 percent of top-load agitators in our current washing machine ratings earn an Excellent score in our cleaning test. Many earn a midrange Good rating, though, meaning they should clean most loads well. They may have trouble with heavily stained or soiled items.

Pretreating laundry with a stain remover will help, and so will pretreating with a dab of laundry detergent that delivers a punch. You can also use a more aggressive wash setting, such as the heavy-soil or heavy-duty cycle, but keep in mind that this is harder on fabrics.

The center-post agitator in these washers churns the laundry, rubbing clothes together to clean them. That’s why many top-load agitators earn only a Good or even a Fair score in our gentleness test. They’re more likely to cause wear and tear to fabrics than, say, a Green Choice front-loader machine that’s very gentle on clothes.

Adjusting the soil setting may help. Use the normal-wash/normal-soil setting for most loads, the light-soil setting when you can, and the delicate cycle when necessary.

All washers use less water than they did 20 years ago because of stricter federal efficiency standards. Top-load agitator washers, however, still typically use more water than HE top-loaders and front-loaders.

In our water-efficiency test, a washer earns an Excellent rating if it uses 13 gallons of water or less. Only five of 40 agitator washers in our ratings hit that mark, whereas most front-loaders and many HE top-loaders earn an Excellent score for water efficiency. In fact, many top-load agitators earn only a Good or Fair rating, using about 16 to 24 gallons to wash an average-sized load.

Doing full loads is one way you can save water. But if you’re not satisfied with how well your washer cleans, check the manual to ensure that you’re not overloading the machine. Dirty laundry needs some room to move around.

As a group, top-load agitator washers are noisier than HE top-loaders or front-loaders. That’s not a big deal if your washer is tucked away in a basement corner, but it can test your patience if the washer sits near your bedroom on the second floor.

Our panelists judge each washer’s noise levels during the fill, agitate/tumble, drain, and spin cycles. None of the agitators in our tests garner an Excellent rating for noise, but a handful earn a Very Good rating, which means they’re audible but not loud enough to disturb you. Most earn a Fair or Good rating, which means they make sustained noise while in use.

Another noise factor to be aware of: If a laundry load gets out of balance, your washer may seem unnervingly, well, agitated. It could make loud thumping sounds, rock back and forth, or even “walk” out of its place. If that happens, stop the wash and move the clothes around to rebalance the load. When the load is done, use a level to make sure the machine sits evenly. Check that the washer is level from front to back and side to side, then tighten the lock nuts on the feet to keep it that way.

Top-load agitators have long been about function instead of form. But manufacturers now offer some models that are more stylish and have larger capacities as well, pushing up prices to between $650 and $1,300. At the same time, prices on other types of washers have come down.

“The appliance industry is very competitive,” Allwood says. “LG and Samsung recently introduced top-load agitator models for the first time. They also make lower-priced, basic HE top-loaders and front-loaders. Other manufacturers have followed suit, so these days top-load agitators might not always be the cheapest option.”

Think your clothes come out cleaner with hot water? Consumer Reports’ appliance expert Emilio Gonzalez explains to “Consumer 101” TV show host Jack Rico why it might not be necessary to wash clothes at a higher temperature.

Keith Flamer

As a kid in Delaware, I lived a few blocks from Bob Marley, who once said, "It is better to live on the house top than to live in a house full of confusion." At CR, I'm psyched to help readers navigate this cluttered, hyper-commercialized world we live in. I've covered luxury real estate, interior design, and culture—reporting on everything from smart home technology to racial hypocrisy at Thomas Jefferson's Monticello estate. Since the pandemic started, I cherish simplicity, covering accessible topics like decorating, cooking, and cleaning. Give me a smoothie blender over a mansion any day. Blenders are slightly easier to clean.

Which is better a washer with or without an agitator?

What is the advantage of no agitator in a washing machine?