Shoulder length dark brown hair with caramel highlights

Opt for a light brown shade that can still add vibrance, like chestnut highlights. Dark brown hair with shades of light brown highlights will still add plenty of dimension to your dark hair without so much contrast. This is ideal if you want brunette strands that are natural and subtle-looking.

"Caramel is always a warm shade, so either way you go, it has to have that perfect balance of warmth," explains colorist and salon owner Rita Hazan.

Find the Right Highlight Shades for You "The best tones on black hair tend to be caramels and lighter browns," explains Papanikolas. And depending on your skin tone, the color can be adjusted to go warmer or cooler to find the most flattering hue for you.